On this page
A founder decides between Sole Proprietorship, LLP, One Person Company (OPC) and Private Limited Company at incorporation. The pitch decks compare cost of setup and compliance overhead. What matters more, and what most comparisons skip, is the tax structure that lives with the business for years.
The headline tax rate
Sole Proprietorship is taxed as the individual owner, at slab rates. Nothing separate. The top rate reaches 30 percent (plus surcharge and cess) once income crosses Rs 15 lakh under the new regime.
LLP is taxed as a firm, flat 30 percent plus surcharge and cess. No lower slabs.
OPC and Private Limited are taxed as domestic companies. The optional 22 percent rate under Section 115BAA (with no exemptions) is what most new companies elect. The old 25 percent for turnover up to Rs 400 crore is still available if you want to keep exemptions like Section 80JJAA.
Manufacturing companies incorporated after October 2019 can elect Section 115BAB at 15 percent, subject to conditions.
Dividend and drawings
Sole Proprietorship: no separate distribution tax. Whatever the business earns is the owner's income. Drawings are not taxed again.
LLP: profits distributed to partners are exempt in the partners' hands because tax has already been paid at the LLP level. Interest on capital and partner remuneration are deductible in the LLP subject to the Section 40(b) limits.
OPC and Private Limited: post-tax profit distributed as dividend is taxable in the shareholder's hands at slab rates. There is no Dividend Distribution Tax any more (removed in 2020), but the shareholder pays. Salaries to a director are deductible in the company and taxable as salary income to the director.
Effective tax on Rs 1 crore profit
This is where the choice becomes real. Take a business earning Rs 1 crore of profit before owner remuneration.
- Proprietorship: roughly 30 percent slab plus 10 percent surcharge and 4 percent cess, effective around 34 percent.
- LLP: 30 percent plus surcharge and cess, effective around 31 to 34 percent depending on income.
- Pvt Ltd under 115BAA: 22 percent plus 10 percent surcharge and 4 percent cess, effective 25.17 percent at the company level. Then dividend on the balance is taxed in the shareholder's hands.
The company path is cheapest if profits stay inside the company (retained for growth). It becomes more expensive if all profits are drawn out as dividend.
Compliance overhead
Proprietorship has the lowest annual compliance: only individual income tax return and, if applicable, GST returns.
LLP: annual return (Form 11), statement of accounts and solvency (Form 8), income tax return. Audit required only if turnover exceeds Rs 40 lakh or contribution exceeds Rs 25 lakh.
OPC and Pvt Ltd: annual return (MGT-7A/MGT-7), financial statement (AOC-4), Director KYC (DIR-3), board meetings, statutory audit regardless of turnover, DIN and DSC renewals.
When each structure wins
Proprietorship wins for a single-founder services business earning under Rs 20 to 30 lakh a year with no plans to raise investment. It is cheapest, fastest, and most tax-efficient at that scale.
LLP wins for a partnership of professionals (chartered accountants, lawyers, consultants) who want limited liability without the compliance cost of a company and do not need equity fundraising.
Private Limited wins the moment fundraising, ESOP, or hiring beyond a handful of employees is on the horizon. VC and angel investors will not put money into an LLP or proprietorship.
OPC is a niche: a single founder who wants limited liability today with a plan to convert to Pvt Ltd on scale. Conversion is a defined process.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch from proprietorship to Pvt Ltd later?
Yes. The process involves incorporating a new company and transferring the business assets and liabilities. It is common at the point of first fundraise.
Does GST apply differently by structure?
No. GST is entity-neutral. The registration threshold and rates are the same across proprietorship, LLP, OPC and Pvt Ltd.
We build GST billing and accounting software for Indian businesses and write about the rules we implement every day. Thresholds and rates are checked against CBIC and Income Tax guidance as of the update date above. For decisions specific to your business, confirm with your CA.