GST Composition Scheme: Who It Suits, Who It Kills

Composition Scheme trades input credit for a low flat rate. When it is a smart choice for a small business, and when it silently costs you customers.

UrbanKhata Editorial Team
Updated · 5 min read
On this page

The Composition Scheme is one of the most misunderstood parts of GST. It sounds like a free ride: pay 1 percent, file quarterly, forget the complexity. In practice, it works beautifully for some businesses and bleeds customers from others. Here is how to tell which one you are.

Who is eligible

You can opt in if your aggregate turnover in the previous financial year did not exceed Rs 1.5 crore for goods and restaurants (Rs 75 lakh in some special category states), or Rs 50 lakh for other services. You cannot opt in if you make inter-state outward supplies, if you sell through an e-commerce operator that collects TCS, if you supply non-taxable goods, or if you are a manufacturer of ice cream, pan masala, tobacco or aerated water.

The rates

They are deliberately low, because in exchange you give up input tax credit and the ability to charge GST separately on your invoice.

  • Traders and manufacturers: 1 percent of turnover (0.5 percent CGST + 0.5 percent SGST).
  • Restaurants that do not serve alcohol: 5 percent (2.5 + 2.5).
  • Other service providers: 6 percent (3 + 3).

When it is a great fit

A neighborhood kirana store, a small stationery shop, a chai stall, or a garment retailer selling entirely to walk-in customers. The buyers are consumers who cannot claim ITC anyway, the tax cost is genuinely low, and quarterly filing (CMP-08 plus an annual GSTR-4) is much less overhead than monthly GSTR-1 plus GSTR-3B.

When it quietly hurts

A B2B services provider whose clients are large companies. Under composition you cannot charge GST separately, and you cannot pass on input credit. Your invoice looks 18 percent cheaper on paper, but the buyer's accounts team compares the true landed cost and typically prefers a regular vendor whose 18 percent is fully recoverable as ITC. You end up either dropping your price by 18 percent, or losing the account.

It also hurts if your business grows quickly. Once you cross the turnover threshold mid-year, you are forced out of the scheme and have to switch to regular filing, often with backdated compliance work.

The invoice difference

A composition dealer must issue a Bill of Supply, not a Tax Invoice. It has to carry the line "composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies." That single line is what makes a B2B buyer walk. It is not a design flaw, it is the design.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch out of composition mid-year?

You can opt out at any time by filing CMP-04, and you must opt out the moment your turnover crosses the threshold. You then move to regular scheme filing from that date.

Can I take input on my old stock when I switch?

Yes. You can claim ITC on inputs held in stock on the day of transition, subject to filing form ITC-01 within 30 days.

Written by the UrbanKhata Editorial Team

We build GST billing and accounting software for Indian businesses and write about the rules we implement every day. Thresholds and rates are checked against CBIC and Income Tax guidance as of the update date above. For decisions specific to your business, confirm with your CA.

Keep reading

All articles

GST invoices, returns and books, in one place.

UrbanKhata turns every invoice into GSTR-1 data, ledger entries and a live P&L. Start on the free plan and add your CA when you're ready.